6 Best Interlocking Puzzle Exercise Mats

There might be affiliate links on this page, which means we get a small commission on anything you buy. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Interlocking puzzle exercise mats are a versatile way to protect your floor and make your workouts more comfortable. Find out what the best options are.

Best interlocking puzzle exercise mats top picks

1. Yes4All Interlocking Exercise Foam Mats (0.44″ = 1.12 cm thick)
2. Stalwart Interlocking Foam Mat Floor Tiles (0.5″ = 1.27 cm thick)
3. Prosource Fit Extra Thick Puzzle Exercise Mat (0.75″ = 1.91 cm thick)
4. BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat (1″ = 2.54 cm thick)
5. We Sell Mats Multipurpose Exercise Floor Mat (0.38″ = 0.97 cm thick)
6. Amazon Basics Foam Interlocking Exercise Mat (0.5″ = 1.27 cm thick)

The thickness of interlocking puzzle exercise mats is one of the main features they vary in. You can see this detail after each of the top picks.

Something else some people will want to know is that the We Sell Mats model is available in a lot of different colors.

How we selected our top picks

Our fitness experts spent a lot of time looking at and comparing all the different important factors of interlocking puzzle exercise mats. Some of the things that were taken into consideration when making our selection include:

• Tile size, minimum square feet purchase, texture, colors available, etc.
• User reviews
• Anecdotal reviews from fitness experts
• Total price, price per square feet, and price per volume
• Brand trustability

If a pick seems interesting click it to see the online prices.

6 Best interlocking puzzle exercise mats reviewed

Different interlocking puzzle exercise mats are often very similar so most people will be able to use the list of top picks to save time and make a quick decision.

That being said, there may be a few differences in details that interest you.

In that case, you can look at each of the best interlocking puzzle exercise mats reviewed in depth to make sure you are choosing the right option for your personal situation.

1. Yes4All Interlocking Exercise Foam Mats

Our top pick for the best interlocking puzzle mats is Yes4All with their Yes4All Interlocking Exercise Foam Mats. You can get these 24″ x 24″ (60.96 cm x 60.96 cm) tiles in three different colors.

Two things to keep in mind are that you need to get at least 24 square feet (2.23 square meters) and that these puzzle exercise mats are somewhat thinner at 0.44″ (1.12 cm).

The surface is designed with anti-slip in mind but like all of the options on this list, you do still want to be careful when using the Yes4All Interlocking Exercise Foam Mats. These are definitely not great outdoor exercise mats.

In any case, this option has a lot of customers who tend to be really happy with their interlocking puzzle exercise mats. On top of that, this option has a budget-friendly price per square foot.

2. Stalwart Interlocking Foam Mat Floor Tiles

The Stalwart Store Interlocking Foam Mat Floor Tiles are just a bit pricier per square foot but cheaper per cubic foot. This is partly because these puzzle mats are a bit thicker at 0.5″ (1.27 cm).

There are definitely still options that are a lot thicker but 0.5″ may suit your exercise needs just a bit better than the previous option without costing as much as the thicker options.

This particular product page does not have the most customers but Stalwart has a variety of interlocking puzzle mats with very positive customer reviews.

3. Prosource Fit Extra Thick Puzzle Exercise Mat

The 0.75″ (1.91 cm) version of the Prosource Fit Extra Thick Puzzle Exercise Mat is somewhat pricer per square foot and cubic foot but this is partly due to the thickness.

While interlocking puzzle exercise mats are very similar from brand to brand, one customer does note that this Prosource Fit model is relatively consistent with height. This helps you avoid stumbling over the grooves.

Besides that, this is another option with a lot of customers who tend to be very happy. If you like one of the three colors available and you are looking for a 0.75″ model, this option can be a good choice.

4. BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat

The BalanceFrom Puzzle Exercise Mat is the thickest option at 1″ (2.54 cm) which makes it somewhat pricier per square foot.

On the other hand, if you take this thickness into account and calculate the price per cubic foot this puzzle exercise mat is on the budget-friendly side.

The thicker surface offers more padding which is especially helpful for tumbling and doing jump exercises like burpees, jumping jacks, and jump squats.

That aside, customer reviews are still very positive but just a bit less so than the previous options. There are just a few more mentions of fast wear and tear and tiles that don’t fit perfectly.

With the high number of customers this is somewhat expected to happen at least a few times. If you want to make sure you have a mat with an even surface and want fewer grooves, you can also consider one of the best folding exercise mats.

That being said, there are still a lot of customers who are really happy with their investment. These are definitely more common than the small complaints.

In short, if you are interested in 1″ (2.54 cm) interlocking puzzle exercise mats this is a quality option that comes at a relatively budget-friendly price per cubic foot.

5. We Sell Mats Multipurpose Exercise Floor Mat

One of the first things that stand out in the We Sell Mats Multipurpose Exercise Floor Mat is the high number of different colors available (13). This is not as essential to your workouts but it is nice to have the choice.

That being said, something that is more important is the thickness of 0.38″ (0.97 cm). This is definitely on the thinner side compared to many other interlocking puzzle exercise mats.

If you plan to do a lot of jumping and really need the padding from the mat to protect your ankles, knees, and back, you likely want to go for one of the other models.

This option from We Sell Mats still has many happy customers but there are better alternatives if you are not interested in the colors.

6. Amazon Basics Foam Interlocking Exercise Mat

The Amazon Basics Foam Interlocking Exercise Mats are budget-friendly puzzle mats with a thickness of 0.5″ (1.27 cm). This budget-friendly aspect applies to both price per square foot and price per cubic foot.

Something you do want to keep in mind is that the reviews are currently just a bit less positive than the previous option with this thickness. There are a few more mentions of the links between the mats being lacking.

That being said, this is still a quality option. If you don’t mind a slightly higher risk on a lacking product, the Amazon Basics Foam Interlocking Exercise Mats can help you save a bit of money, especially if you are creating an extra large exercise mat.