There might be affiliate links on this page, which means we get a small commission on anything you buy. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
The Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 are two very similar elliptical machines. Find out their subtle differences and what the best choice is for you.
Some of the main differences between the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 are that the Nautilus E616 has slightly longer warranties in certain areas, negligibly different dimensions, a Bluetooth heart rate chest strap, and at the time of writing a price that is a nice amount more budget-friendly.
On the other hand, the Schwinn 470 has a slightly heavier flywheel for smoother workouts, a slightly lighter weight, and negligibly different dimensions.
First of all, any temporary deals and price differences could play a big role in your decision. These elliptical machines are very similar and owned by the same company.
That being said, if these machines were a similar price there would still be ways to make a decision.
If you want slightly longer mechanical parts, electronics, and labor warranties, the Nautilus E616 is likely the right choice.
The heart rate monitor is another nice addition on paper but some customers mention you should not expect too much of this.
If you want workouts that are just a bit smoother and/or plan to move your machine around a lot instead, you can choose the Schwinn 470.
Differences Nautilus E616 vs Schwinn 470
At first sight, the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 look the same. However, there are some subtle differences that can play a role in your decision.
| Feature | Nautilus E616 | Schwinn 470 |
|---|---|---|
| Flywheel Weight | 17 lbs (11.3 kg) | 20 lbs (9.1 kg) |
| Warranties* | 10 Years Frame Warranty, 3 Years Mechanical Parts And Electronics Warranty, 1 Year Labor Warranty | 10 Years Frame Warranty, 2 Years Mechanical Parts Warranty, 1 Year Electronics Warranty, 90 Days Labor Warranty |
| Weight | 173.3 lbs (78.6 kg) | 164 lbs (74.5 kg) |
| Dimensions | 70″ L x 28″ W x 71″ H | 70.1″ L x 28.2″ W x 63.2″ H |
| Heart Rate Monitor | Contact And Included Bluetooth Chest Strap | Contact And Bluetooth Chest Strap (Bought Separately) |
| Price Category** | $$$ | $$$$ |
| Check Current Price | Check Current Price |
*Warranties can vary from seller to seller
**Price category at the time of writing
Common features Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470
Before investing in either the Nautilus E616 or the Schwinn 470, you may also want to take another look at their common features.
| Feature | Nautilus E616 | Schwinn 470 |
|---|---|---|
| Weight Limit | 300 Pounds (136 kg) | 300 Pounds (136 kg) |
| Resistance Levels | 25 Levels | 25 Levels |
| Incline Options | To 10 Degrees, Motorized | To 10 Degrees, Motorized |
| Step Up Height | Not Mentioned, Some Reviews Say 12″ | Not Mentioned |
| Foldable | No | No |
| Stride | 20″ (50.8 cm) | 20″ (50.8 cm) |
| Transport Wheels | Yes | Yes |
| Moving Handles | Straight Grip Only | Straight Grip Only |
| Controls On Moving Handles | No | No |
| Additional Static Handles | Yes | Yes |
| Adjustable Pedals | Articulating Footplates | No |
| Pedal Cushions | Not Mentioned | Not Mentioned |
| Screen | Backlit LCD Display | 2 DualTrack Blue Backlit LCD |
| Workout Programs | 29 Programs And Compatible With Certain Apps | 29 Programs And Compatible With Certain Apps |
| Device Holder | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth Compatibility | Yes | Yes |
| Speakers | Yes | Yes |
| Bluetooth Audio Capabilities | Not Mentioned | Yes |
| Cooling Fans | Yes | Yes |
| Resistance Type | Magnetic | Magnetic |
| Check Current Price | Check Current Price |
Differences Nautilus E616 vs Schwinn 470 explained
If you are familiar with elliptical machine features and know what you want in them, you could be able to make a decision based on the feature and price differences.
On the other hand, you may still be unsure what certain features mean, how they influence your experience, and to what extent they should play a role in your decision.
Flywheel weight
A flywheel of an elliptical machine is the rotating disk the pedals are attached to. This component can vary between models in terms of details like weight.
The Nautilus E616 has a flywheel weight of 17 lbs (11.3 kg). The flywheel of the Schwinn 470 is slightly heavier at 20 lbs (9.1 kg).
A general guideline is that heavier flywheels tend to be preferred. The main reason for this is that they build up more momentum than lighter models.
This makes it so the pedals are more likely to keep rotating smoothly even when/if you don’t time your pressure on the pedals perfectly.
Additionally, a heavier flywheel is a bit harder to get and keep going. Especially during the horizontal push and pull movements. That being said, due to the extra momentum, this second effect is relatively small.
In short, workouts with the heavier flywheel of the Schwinn 470 will be just a bit smoother.
Winner: Schwinn 470
Warranties
Warranties are how long a brand is willing to replace certain components if they break down under normal use. Elliptical machines often vary in this area.
This also applies to the models in this comparison. The Nautilus E616 has 10 years frame warranty, 3 years mechanical parts and electronics warranty, and 1 year labor warranty.
Some warranties of the Schwinn 470 are just a bit shorter. This elliptical machine has 10 years frame warranty, 2 years mechanical parts warranty, 1 year electronics warranty, and 90 days labor warranty.
Even if you don’t have to use these warranties, they are somewhat of an indication of how much a brand stands behind the quality of its product.
The Nautilus E616 does just a bit better in this area even though Schwinn Fitness is owned by the same company.
How important the warranties are to you depends on things like how long you plan to use your elliptical machine and how risk tolerant you are.
Winner: Nautilus E616
Weight
The weight of an elliptical machine is a relatively straightforward feature but you may be unsure about how this detail matters in any way.
First of all, there are a few situations where the floor has a limited weight capacity. In these situations, you want to take a careful look at the weight of each elliptical machine you are considering.
That being said, most people will care about the weights of the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 in regards to moving the machines around.
Both elliptical machines have transport wheels. However, it will be just a bit harder to move around the 173.3 lbs (78.6 kg) of the Nautilus E616 than the 164 lbs (74.5 kg) of the Schwinn 470.
This is a small difference that will likely not influence your decision too much.
However, it may be something to keep in mind if you plan to move your elliptical machine a lot in between workouts and if you are not that strong.
Winner: Schwinn 470
Price
The Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 each have their advantages and disadvantages. Something that could make your decision easier is any big price differences.
Exactly how much each machine costs depends on where you get them and can change over time. That being said, at the time of writing, the Nautilus E616 is a nice amount more budget-friendly than the Schwinn 470.
Even so, because these machines are so similar and from the same company, there may be temporary deals that swing the advantage one way or the other.
You definitely want to check this detail in the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 before making your decision.
Winner: Nautilus E616 at the time of writing but can vary
User reviews
When comparing two elliptical machines from the same company like the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470, the feature and price differences typically give a good idea about what option the best is for you.
Even so, you can sometimes discover unexpected downsides or trends in quality issues when taking a look at the customer reviews.
In the case of the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470, the customer reviews are very similar. Users generally like the actual workouts on the elliptical machines but there are also things that can be better.
First of all, there are a decent number of mentions about the screens of these elliptical machines being relatively basic.
Secondly, there are a few cases of faulty parts and early wear and tear. In these situations, the customer support departments can be a bit slow to respond and solve the issues.
Lastly, the two static handlebars in the middle are positioned relatively low. Taller individuals may not be able to hold these comfortably.
You want to keep the things above in mind before investing in these elliptical machines. At the same time, customers are still somewhat positive about the Nautilus E616 and Schwinn 470 overall.
Is the Nautilus E616 or Schwinn 470 right for you?
In short, the Nautilus E616 has slightly longer warranties in certain areas, negligibly different dimensions, a Bluetooth heart rate chest strap, and at the time of writing a price that is a nice amount more budget-friendly.
The Schwinn 470 has a slightly heavier flywheel for smoother workouts, a slightly lighter weight, and negligibly different dimensions.
Because these two elliptical machines and from the same company, any temporary deals could swing your decision one way or the other.
If/when these machines are a similar price your decision depends on your preferences in certain areas.
People who want slightly longer warranties in certain areas can choose the Nautilus E616.
Individuals who want workouts that are just a bit smoother and/or plan to move their machines around a lot can choose the Schwinn 470 with its slightly heavier flywheel and somewhat lighter weight.
Related posts:
